GrafZahl [he/him]

  • 8 Posts
  • 85 Comments
Joined 5 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 22nd, 2020

help-circle


  • I agree with everything you said. I did not claim that corporations would stop a “VPN ban”, and as you said, a “VPN ban” would not try to ban VPNs, but it would target any kind of anonymity. Opposition to this should of course be supported. The law is an obvious deception to give law enforcement more power to use against anyone they wish, and terrible humor is my coping mechanism.

    Now to your point about stopping 95% of the population from hiding their ID online, have they done so successfully in the past? I’m not trying to pin down the number, I get that it’s probably just an estimation and youre talking about the “average person online”. My guess would be, they use a VPN at best, but they do not use it in a way that actually makes them anonymous, like they would still log onto their E-Mail and Facebook and whatnot. My understanding is, that this makes any VPN useless for anonymity, but please correct me if that’s wrong, I admit I’m not super well informed on that.

    In my experience, and anyone I talk to in real life, the advice is to generally not even use phones to talk/message about organizing stuff. I mostly go by the assumption that the average person is already not able to hide their identity online, other than by “hiding in the crowd”. Right now, the amount of data makes it hard for anyone to find anything, so people still get away with a lot of shit because noone is looking at them too closely. I think this might soon end, as law enforcement is starting to use software tools from Palantir, and the biggest critics of those tools in germany are apparently opposed to it, because it is a US product, and not a EU product. Police has not been bothered to check whether the use of this software to indiscriminately analyse personal data is even legal. Courts might intervene, but I’m not sure how relevant that is, because they will probably still allow the use of such tools in some capacity, and then police can just do some oopsies and use it illegally anyways.

    I don’t wanna dismiss people who rely on online communication a lot, I get that it’s important for many. I think E-Mail and encrypted messaging in 1on1 messages is still sort of safe? But I wouldn’t be surprised if that also has no future. Eventually the state figured out they could just open the mail of a “suspect”, why wouldn’t they do the same with online comms?