• OBJECTION!@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 day ago

    The original claim was that the founders were “antifascists.”

    Personally, I wouldn’t call them fascist or antifascist because I disagree with the definition that extends fascism back to include all monarchies and such. I prefer to use a narrower definition of it, because the conditions of Germany, Italy, and other fascist countries were very different from the feudal system that had existed further back in the past, and it’s more useful and accurate to have a word that describes those conditions specifically. Otherwise, I think we’re diluting the term and making it much more nebulous.

    Trying to fit the founders into one of these boxes of “fascist” or “antifascist” is projecting modern politics into a historical situation where it doesn’t really apply, rather than simply seeing what was. That broad way of thinking is something I consider wrong and dangerous, whatever the categories are. For example, during the Cold War, the US saw the world in terms of “communist” or “not communist” and everyone, everywhere in the world had to fit into one of those categories. Anti-colonial struggles, such as in Iran, were labelled as communist even when they weren’t. Reality is far more complex than such broad oversimplifications allow for.

    The British system, for example, was a constitutional monarchy (still is) where power was shared between the monarchy and parliament. But even before parliament, feudal systems were more complex than just “whatever the king says goes,” there were layers upon layers of contracts between each level of noble that said what they could and couldn’t do, and a king that violated those contracts would likely face a rebellion from the nobility. Meanwhile, the system in Nazi Germany was designed to encourage different branches of government competing against each other, making it somewhat less cohesive and centralized than is often imagined.

    • LustyArgonian@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 day ago

      Modern fascism came from feudalist practices though. Nothing exists outside of historical context.

      The point isn’t to call them any specific label per se, the point is that these same desires that our country was built on would be labeled antifascist today by the current fascist government that is gaslighting us that they care about these laws and the founding fathers and constitution.